Q&A: Solving A Problem Between Two Brothers

It is commendable that you want to solve the problem between two brothers. At the very least, you will benefit from not having to hear the complaints and be in the middle of the conflict, since you are friends with both.

by Deedra Abboud in Q&A, Social Views, Solutions
January 21, 2016 0 comments

Dear Deedra,

I am friends with two brothers, one of them is a very close friend. Despite living in the same city, they have not spoken or visited each other in several years. During that time, their children have gotten married, had children of their own, and two of their siblings died. Neither attend the weddings or births of the other, and each had separate gatherings following the sibling deaths.
My best friend did not invite his brother to any of his family events and told me his brother has never called him or invite him to any of his family events. The other brother said he had called several times, but his brother never answers and never calls back, and that his son had personally visited his uncle to deliver the invitation for his own wedding, but my friend’s family still did not attend.

I know it is because my best friend’s wife does not like the brother or his family. I know she is the problem. She does not want her husband to have anything to do with his brother, so he doesn’t.

I want to bring the brothers together. I hate being in the middle. Both the brothers complain to me every time I see them. I keep trying to get them together, without the wife. The other brother always agrees, but my best friend has absolutely refused to meet his brother to try to solve the problem.

What should I do?

Brother Problem Solver
Dear Brother Problem Solver:

First, it is commendable that you want to solve the problem between two brothers. I do not know what faith you are, if any at all, but according to Islam there is a great reward from God for attempting to solve the problems between people – as I am sure is also the case in all other faiths. At the very least, you will benefit from not having to hear the complaints and be in the middle of the conflict, since you are friends with both.

Second, a spouse should never come between two brothers, or any other family relationship. Family is family, and though we might not always get along with our in-laws or extended family, we should never attempt to taint their relationship with each other. A spouse can choose to limit his or her own interaction without making such demands on the other spouse.

Unfortunately, I see all too often one spouse getting treated poorly by family members and the other spouse living in the oblivion of denial. Spouses need to remember that we do not always see things the same, but we must always, if not out-right defend, at least privately support our spouses.

This will go a long way in helping the “victim” spouse overlook the offenses. Otherwise, it is a denial (opposite of validating) of the “victim” spouse’s feelings, leading to constant feelings of victimhood and meltdowns over minor issues.

This is true for both genders, not just women.

Third, you are blaming the wife, but in the end the husband is ultimately at fault for his own choices. Regardless of how the wife is feeling, or what the wife is saying, the husband/brother is choosing to sever the relationship with his brother. It is a choice. Even if it is choosing the security of his wife over his brother, it is a choice.

The brother also has the choice to set boundaries, either with his brother or his wife, or both, and maintain a relationship with both. Obviously, for whatever reason, he is not choosing to do so. Instead, choosing just to cut off his brother.

Fourth, it appears your friend is not being honest with you about the problem in the first place. He told you his brother does not call him and never invited him to functions. His brother told you differently. One of them is not being honest. Only one of them, your best friend, is refusing to meet to solve the problem. That is a good indicator of who is not being totally honest with you about the situation.

Lastly, I would suggest your best friend is not sharing his problem with you in search of a solution, but rather 1) to justify, and get you to validate, his own choice to cut-off his brother, and/or 2) to taint your relationship with his brother.

Neither of these possibilities are good for you or your relationship to either one.

Bottom line, if he does not want to fix the problem, there is no need for him to continue to share the problem, and the stress, with you. And you need to tell him that directly. . . clearly.

It is on you to create the boundary. Otherwise, you are just part of the problem between the brothers – and choosing to remain so.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.